Browse / Books like… / The Midnight Library

Books Like The Midnight Library

If The Midnight Library by Matt Haig worked for you, these indie books offer a similar reading experience. The comparison comes from AI analysis of each full manuscript (pacing, tone, tropes, and more), not from marketing copy.

Cover of Unconditional: A Story of Fatherhood, Lost Love, and Lifelong Friendship

Unconditional: A Story of Fatherhood, Lost Love, and Lifelong Friendship

Stephen Kogon

She wasn't his daughter. But she made him a father. When Matthew's brother dies, leaving behind a newborn daughter, he must choose between walking away or raising her as his own. Spanning eighteen years, Unconditional is a heartfelt father-daughter story about family, loss, and unconditional love.

Domestic
A

Always the Land

Diane Haugen

This book tells a story of my uncle, Dale Goldsmith, and his lifelong relationship to a land that many see as worthless. The spirit of the land is untamable, in essence unnamable, something the counters of officially significant things in this life cannot comprehend. In spirit, my feelings reach beyond my personal memories, transcending the clutter of everyday life, becoming a part of the overarching vastness that finds an outward and powerful expression in this magnificent land of little worldly significance.

Historical Fiction
Cover of The Castaway

The Castaway

Stephanie Taylor

Ruby Hudson used to be America’s First Lady. Now she just wants to be left alone with her books and her regrets. After her husband—the President of the United States—dies under mysterious circumstances, Ruby is left with a lifetime of questions, a public still obsessed with her every move, and two grown daughters who think she's lost her mind. So, she runs. Not to a fancy villa or a European spa, but to a pirate-themed island called Shipwreck Key, where she opens a tiny bookshop and tries to disappear. No press. No politics. Just quiet. Until he shows up. Dexter North is too young, too intense, and way too determined to dig up every secret of her late husband's presidency—including the kind that could ruin his legacy... and Ruby’s life. He’s charming in that annoyingly earnest journalist way, and unfortunately, he’s not going anywhere. Then, as if things weren’t complicated enough, the President’s secret mistress arrives. With their twelve-year-old son. And a letter. From her husband. Written before he died. Now Ruby has to decide: does she open the letter and face the truth about the man she thought she knew? Or does she let the past stay buried and try—finally—to start over? On a quirky island full of castaways and second chances, one former First Lady is about to rewrite her own story.

Women's Fiction

Want a match tuned to your exact taste?

Describe what you loved about The Midnight Library in plain English and Deep Match will search the full text of every book in the catalog.

Try Deep Match